How do we ensure your chocolate won't melt during the shipping process?

During warm weather months, chocolates must be shipped with ice packs and coolers for a $5 handling fee. If your area is not experiencing warm temperatures, the $5 handling fee will be waived.

Peanut Butter Buckeyes

(31 reviews) Write a Review
Gift wrapping:
Options available

A Buckeye from the Buckeye State! The Peanut Butter Buckeye is a traditional Ohio favorite. We blend our peanut butter center using our time-honored recipe and then hand dip each Buckeye in premium milk chocolate. 8 oz.

Each 8 oz. box contains 15 Buckeyes.

31 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5

    Posted by Melissa R on Nov 14th 2022

    The best Buckeyes I've ever had. I received my order with in few days if ordering. I highly recommend using this company.

  • 5

    Posted by Jennifer on Apr 8th 2022

    Our favorites!

  • 5

    Posted by Nina on Jan 29th 2022


  • 5
    Gift for my grandson-in-law

    Posted by Rebecca R on Dec 22nd 2021

    The very best company with fantastic products.

  • 5

    Posted by Kelly on Dec 15th 2021

    Fast delivery and tastes great. I miss them since I have moved to Florida. Glad to have them back again.

  • 5

    Posted by Jean on Dec 13th 2021

    These are delicious. Not to sweet but just right amount of chocolate to peanut butter.

  • 5
    peanut butter buckeyes

    Posted by Penelope P on Dec 6th 2021

    My maiden name is Coblentz and I grew up in New Madison, Ohio. I have given this product a couple of times at Christmas to my friends in Texas and they always begged for more.

  • 5
    Great Candy

    Posted by Irene K on Nov 22nd 2021

    Originally tried these on a trip to Ohio to see the Cleveland Indians.

  • 5
    Peanut Butter Buckeyes

    Posted by Karen E W on Sep 16th 2021

    Wonderful gifts.