How do we ensure your chocolate won't melt during the shipping process?

During warm weather months, chocolates must be shipped with ice packs and coolers for a $5 handling fee. If your area is not experiencing warm temperatures, the $5 handling fee will be waived.

Peanut Butter Buckeyes

(30 reviews) Write a Review
Gift wrapping:
Options available

A Buckeye from the Buckeye State! The Peanut Butter Buckeye is a traditional Ohio favorite. We blend our peanut butter center using our time-honored recipe and then hand dip each Buckeye in premium milk chocolate. 8 oz.

Each 8 oz. box contains 15 Buckeyes.

30 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Create Your Own Box

    Posted by Nina G on Feb 26th 2021

    I simply LOVE this feature!!! My daughter usually doesn't like boxed candy, but she adored these chocolates!!! I choose things she had not been able to find anywhere else and she just loved all the choices!!! We will order again!!! Thank You!!!

  • 5
    Peanut Butter Buckeyes

    Posted by Nina G on Feb 26th 2021

    Very Good!!! Hubby Loved Them!!! We will order again!!! Thank You!!!

  • 5

    Posted by Melissa R on Feb 10th 2021

    These Buckeyes are amazingly delicious!
    I will be getting more very soon, because they were eaten quickly.

  • 5

    Posted by Doris J B on Dec 15th 2020

    we and all our family enjoy your products,and how do I know, because they eat a lot of ours.

  • 5
    Other than homemade, Coblentz Buckeyes are THE BEST!

    Posted by Mary E. M on Dec 1st 2020

    My best friend from Canton, OH, lives in Rhode Island and is a self-proclaimed "buckeye expert." She says Coblentz are the best...superior to Harry London and Waggoner's.

  • 5
    Peanut Butter Buckeyes

    Posted by Kristina K on Nov 18th 2020

    Delicious and fast shipping. It was packed with ice packs to keep it fresh. Highly recommend!

  • 5
    Peanut Butter Buckeyes

    Posted by Karen E. W on Nov 12th 2020

    11 boxes of Colbentz Peanut Butter Buckeyes were enjoyed by the Cedarville High School cross country team after the State Finals.
    The boxes were empty when arrived back in Cedarville. Wonderful gift to give and they enjoyed them!

  • 5
    Best Peanut Butter Buckeyes!

    Posted by Wanda Malloris on May 21st 2020

    Melt in your mouth Peanut Butter Buckeyes! Hard to eat just one of these! If you haven't tried them yet, you're missing out on pure deliciousness!

  • 5
    "the best"

    Posted by Kay C. on May 20th 2020

    Again- sent this to my aunt and uncle in Kewaskum, Wisconsin for their 71st wedding anniversary! they are 91 and 94 and living at home. they absolutely raved about your candy!
    keep up the good work!